Retaining Dignity in Autonomous and AI-Mediated Warfare
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18716/ojs/phai/2026.3309Keywords:
Dignity, AI, Autonomous Weapon Systems, Military Ethics, Digital DehumanizationAbstract
In the debates surrounding autonomous weapon systems (AWS) and AI-enabled systems in the military, ``"dignity" often comes to the fore in critics' objections, and though some critical voices are skeptical of the ultimate value of dignity in discussions of morality and law in war, there are those who treat the concept as the ultimate objection, subject to no rebuttal from either philosophical arguments or ``"technical improvements". However, as we argue in this article, whether one treats dignity in terms of some special status or worth humans possess, or as requiring that one treat others with the respect due to them in virtue of their humanity (à la Kant), dignity fails to provide a convincing objection to AWS or AI-enabled systems in the military without also objecting to much of modern warfare as such. More than this, we argue that dignity is a concept fundamentally out of place in discussions on the morality or legality of war. We further argue that, its general inaptness for regulating conduct in war notwithstanding, the value of dignity may actually be furthered through the use of AWS and AI-enabled systems. We conclude by showing that a careful appraisal of dignity-based objections highlights that these by and large betray a fundamental failure to either grasp or appropriately address the realities of warfighting, and what those realities mean for considerations of dignity in war.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 1970 Nathan Gabriel Wood, Juan Ignacio del Valle

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.




